Cold Sore Treatment Advisor
Find Your Best Treatment Option
Answer a few questions to get personalized recommendations for cold sore treatment.
Recommended Treatment
When a cold sore pops up, you don’t have time for guesswork. You need something that works fast, and you want to know if the brand you’re reaching for - like Zovirax Cream - is really the best option. Many people assume Zovirax is the gold standard because it’s been around for decades. But is it still the top choice in 2025? Or are newer, cheaper, or more effective alternatives out there?
What Zovirax Cream Actually Does
Zovirax Cream contains acyclovir a topical antiviral medication used to treat herpes simplex virus infections, including cold sores and genital herpes. It doesn’t cure the virus - no treatment does. But it slows down how fast the virus multiplies, which helps reduce swelling, redness, and how long the sore lasts.
Studies show that when you start using acyclovir cream at the very first sign - that tingling or itching before the blister forms - you can cut the healing time by about one day on average. For some people, it stops the sore from even forming. That’s why timing matters more than the brand.
The cream comes in a 5% concentration. You apply it five times a day for four to five days. It’s not a miracle cure, but it’s reliable. And because it’s been on the market since the 1980s, doctors still recommend it.
How Other Topical Antivirals Stack Up
There are three other topical antiviral creams you’ll find in pharmacies today. Each has different strengths, prices, and availability.
- Denavir (penciclovir) - This is the closest competitor to Zovirax. It works similarly but has a longer half-life in the skin, meaning you only need to apply it every two hours (four times a day). Some users report faster pain relief. A 2023 clinical review in the Journal of Dermatological Treatment found penciclovir reduced healing time by 1.2 days compared to placebo - slightly better than acyclovir’s 0.9 days.
- Abreva (docosanol) - This one’s different. It’s not an antiviral. Instead, it blocks the virus from entering skin cells. It’s available over-the-counter without a prescription. Studies show it shortens healing time by about half a day. It’s less effective than acyclovir or penciclovir, but it’s cheaper and easier to get.
- Virasoothe (lysine-based cream) - This isn’t FDA-approved for treating herpes. It’s sold as a “cold sore relief” product. It contains lysine, amines, and soothing agents like aloe. It helps with itching and drying, but there’s no solid evidence it fights the virus itself.
Price and Accessibility Compared
Cost matters - especially if you get cold sores often. Here’s what you’re looking at in Australia as of late 2025:
| Product | Active Ingredient | Prescription Needed? | Price (3g tube) | Application Frequency | Healing Time Reduction |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zovirax Cream | Acyclovir 5% | No (OTC) | $22.50 | 5 times daily | 0.8-1.1 days |
| Denavir | Penciclovir 1% | Yes | $38.00 | 4 times daily | 1.0-1.3 days |
| Abreva | Docosanol 10% | No | $16.90 | 5 times daily | 0.4-0.6 days |
| Virasoothe | Lysine, aloe | No | $14.50 | 3-4 times daily | None proven |
Abreva is the most affordable and easiest to get. Zovirax is a solid middle ground - effective, widely available, and covered by the PBS if you have a prescription. Denavir works better but costs nearly double and needs a doctor’s note. Virasoothe? Save your money unless you just want something soothing.
When to Choose What
Here’s how to pick based on your situation:
- First-time outbreak or mild case? Start with Abreva. It’s cheap, safe, and might help enough.
- Get cold sores often (4+ times a year)? Talk to your GP about a prescription for Denavir or acyclovir cream. The faster healing saves you from discomfort and social stress.
- Want the most proven option? Zovirax is still the most studied. It’s the default choice for many GPs and pharmacists.
- On a tight budget and can’t see a doctor? Stick with Abreva. It’s not as strong, but it’s better than nothing.
- Just want relief from burning or itching? Virasoothe or even a simple lip balm with zinc oxide might feel better - even if it doesn’t shorten the outbreak.
What Doesn’t Work (And Why People Waste Money)
There’s a lot of noise out there. You’ll see ads for:
- Essential oil blends (tea tree, peppermint) - These can irritate skin and may even trigger more outbreaks.
- “Boost your immunity with lysine pills” - Oral lysine has weak, inconsistent evidence. Topical lysine creams like Virasoothe? Even weaker.
- Alcohol swabs or toothpaste - These dry out the skin, cause more pain, and don’t touch the virus.
- “Natural antiviral” supplements - No credible study shows any supplement prevents or treats cold sores.
Don’t fall for quick fixes. The virus lives in your nerve cells. Topical treatments only work on the surface. The only proven way to reduce outbreaks long-term is oral antivirals like valacyclovir - but those require a prescription and are meant for frequent sufferers.
Pro Tips for Better Results
Even the best cream won’t help if you use it wrong.
- Apply at the first sign - tingling, burning, or itching. Once the blister forms, it’s too late for maximum effect.
- Wash your hands before and after. Don’t touch your eye or other people’s skin.
- Use a cotton swab, not your finger. That reduces spreading.
- Don’t peel off the scab. Let it fall off naturally.
- Use sunscreen on your lips daily. UV light is a major trigger.
Also, avoid kissing, sharing lip balm, or touching your face during an outbreak. Cold sores are contagious until fully healed - usually 7-10 days.
What About Oral Antivirals?
If you get cold sores more than four times a year, or if they’re severe, topical creams alone aren’t enough. Oral antivirals like valacyclovir (Valtrex) or acyclovir tablets work better because they reach the virus where it hides - in your nerves.
A 2024 study in the Australian Journal of General Practice found that people who took valacyclovir at the first sign cut their outbreak duration by 2-3 days and reduced severity by 70%. That’s better than any cream.
But you need a prescription. Talk to your doctor if you’re dealing with frequent outbreaks. They might give you a script to keep on hand.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Zovirax Cream better than Abreva?
Yes, for treating the virus itself. Zovirax (acyclovir) reduces healing time by about a day, while Abreva (docosanol) only cuts it by half a day. But Abreva is cheaper and doesn’t need a prescription. If your outbreaks are mild, Abreva might be enough. For frequent or painful sores, Zovirax is more effective.
Can I use Zovirax Cream on genital herpes?
No. Zovirax Cream is only approved for cold sores (oral herpes). For genital herpes, you need either oral antivirals or a different topical formulation prescribed by a doctor. Using the cream on genital areas can cause irritation and won’t treat the infection properly.
Is there a generic version of Zovirax Cream?
Yes. Generic acyclovir 5% cream is available in Australia under brands like Acivir or Acyclovir Sandoz. It’s the same active ingredient, same effectiveness, and costs about half as much. Ask your pharmacist - they often stock it behind the counter.
Does Zovirax Cream prevent cold sores?
No. It only treats outbreaks once they start. To prevent cold sores, you need to avoid triggers like stress, sun exposure, or illness. For people with frequent outbreaks, daily oral antivirals (like valacyclovir) can reduce how often they happen - but that requires a prescription.
How long does Zovirax Cream last once opened?
The tube is usually good for 12 months after opening, but check the label. If it changes color, smells odd, or becomes grainy, throw it out. Using expired cream won’t harm you, but it won’t work either.
Final Thoughts
Zovirax Cream isn’t perfect, but it’s still one of the most reliable options for cold sores. It’s not the fastest, not the cheapest, but it’s the most proven. If you’re looking for better results, Denavir is slightly more effective - but only if you’re willing to pay more and get a prescription. For most people, Abreva is a practical first step. And if you’re tired of dealing with cold sores every few months, talk to your doctor about oral antivirals. That’s where real prevention starts.
Don’t waste money on miracle creams or supplements. Stick to what science backs up. And remember - the earlier you treat it, the better it gets.
Comments
j jon October 29, 2025 at 11:00
Been using Zovirax since college and it’s never failed me. I apply it the second I feel that tingle-no waiting. Works every time. I don’t care what’s new or cheaper; if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.